From time to time, I talk to managers and they tell me about their teams and say things like “we get on really well, we are really good friends”. It is lovely to have such a close connection with the people you work with … but it can lead to problems if you are not careful.
We all know that we work better when we are happier. We work better when we feel appreciated and recognised. We work harder for managers we feel connected to. Those are all well established facts, so it is easy for newer managers to feel that creating a friendly atmosphere is the right approach. BUT …. there is a difference between being friendly and friends and there are dangers with being too friendly with staff members.
Be true to yourself
If you really get on with your team mates and being friends is a natural result of that, then that is fine. But I have seen instances where new managers think that they way to get their team “on board” is to be their best mate. They go out of their way to be friends with everyone on their team.
if you are trying to appear friendly, then people will spot it. Those managers who try too hard to be all “pally” get found out. We can all spot fakes, we feel it in our gut. When people see a manager is being un-authentic, they lose the respect for the manager, it puts a strain of friendships and it does disrupt the team dynamics.
Providing bad news
Now, let’s imagine you are really good mates with someone you manage. You have to tell them that their work has not been of the right quality. Could you look your mate in the eye and tell them that their work has been poor?
Or imagine that they think they are ready to be promoted but you don’t think they are ready. Can you tell them that they are not getting put forward for promotion and explain why?
If you are good friends with your team member, you have an emotional bond that is stronger and untangling those emotions from the needs of the role can be very difficult. I am not saying that you cannot be friends with someone you manager, but you must understand that it can complicate things.
I suggest the two of you have an open chat about it and the challenges it may throw up and agree how you will face them.
Treating people equally
If you have a team of 4 people and you are really good friends with two of them, how will the others feel? Will they start to wonder if there is preferential treatment being given to the friends?
And can you be sure that you don’t treat friends differently? Isn’t that the benefit of being friends, that you get treated with more consideration than someone who is merely an acquaintance?
You are paid to be a manager
You are paid to deliver your team goals and you are paid to develop the team. That is your role description. As part of that, you have to hold your team to account. You may need to set them targets that push them out of their comfort zone to make sure they become more rounded. You may need them to put in extra hours to meet a deadline, or work on a project that they don’t want to. That can be a lot harder with people you are friends with.
I mention these risks because I have seen these instances first hand. I have seen managers who have avoided difficult conversations with staff because they don’t want to upset them. I have seen managers inadvertently create division and unrest by being too friendly with their team.
And this is where the idea of authenticity needs careful handling. If you are a warm and friendly person who loves harmony and loves making friends, how do you square that with needing to draw boundaries? The answer is that an authentic leader is true to themselves but put the mission and the goals of the organisation ahead of their own self-interest. This is a very important distinction for Authentic Leaders in that they do the job to get the results, not to amass power or massage their ego … or to make friends.
Recent Comments