For my first post of 2015, I am going to start with a whinge. It concerns the apparent “conflict” between being a manager and being a leader.

Let me explain, if you follow leadership blogs like I do, sometimes, you can be forgiven for thinking that “manager bad, leader good”. There are blogs and tweets on the comparative merits of being a manager and being a leader and I have even felt that some people talk about it as if it was a binary situation. You are either a manager or a leader. IT IS ANNOYING ME.

I see posts telling me that a manager has an authoritarian style, that they manage work, that they are seek short-term goals, whilst leaders ride white horses, leap buildings in a single leap and are so charismatic that people go all weak at the knees.

Clearly, this is balderdash.

 

It feels to me as if some people are mixing up different themes and coming up with overly simple answers.

Here is my view.

 

1) We perform different roles during our career.

In our working lives, we all have times when we just “do-the-do”. We turn up, shuffle paper, man the machine, pick up the phone. Many of us have times when we are responsible for a team of people who shuffle paper, man the machine, pick up the phone. And some of us have times when we set the direction for managers of people who shuffle paper, man the machine, pick up the phone.

People can go through life moving from being “operating” to “organising” to “transforming” … and back again as their situation changes.

If you work in a call centre answering the phones, it is likely that 95% of your job is “operating”. If you are the team leader, it is likely that some of your work is still “operating”, you fill out admin forms or you input data, you may even answer a call or two when someone wants to speak to the supervisor. But you also spend a lot of time scheduling and organising. It maybe that you are asked to undertake some small projects to change how your team operates and this will be your first steps into transforming. As the call centre manager, your role may well be focussed on changing the culture, inspiring your team to innovate, to do more transformational stuff.

 

2) It is the “HOW” that sets us apart.

My view is that when commentators talk about management versus leadership, they are talking about styles. But styles are not binary, there are a number of styles. There are lots of academic models on leadership/management styles.

What is interesting is that many of these models also state that styles have to suit a given situation. If a building is burning, implementing a “coaching” style may have catastrophic consequences. What you want is some to say “You lot leave your desks and walk calmly to the fire exit … NOW”. When I managed an IT support team and we had an IT crisis, someone has to take control and say “You ring the client, you start the diagnostics tracker, you make the tea!”. Clearly, in that instance, I am being authoritative, it is a “do what I say” style.

If I used this style for the rest of the time, I think we all know that I would not have been a very successful manager. My success was based on my ability to implement different styles with different people at different times.

So please don’t write blogs telling me that managers are bad and just tell people what to do while leaders inspire and energise. I have known enough managers who inspire and energise and enough leaders who crush all imagination to show otherwise.

The point of the blog is actually to say that being a manager in an organisation is much more complex than all that. It is the ability to implement different approaches to a given situation to get the desired response. That is not binary.

 

I offer people training and coaching to help them develop the wide set of skills required to manage effectively no matter the situation. Contact Me to find out how I can help your managers perform better.